By I. Nelson Rose
Futures prediction markets have recently gotten a lot of attention. And not in a good way.
On July 8, 2026, the Southern District of New York denied Kalshi’s attempt to prevent the state of New York from enforcing its gambling laws against the big prediction market company. In the important decision, the federal judge in Manhattan ruled protecting the people of New York from compulsive gambling, endangering sports integrity and a proliferation of unregulated contracts, heavily outweighed Kalshi’s interests in ensuring the primacy of federal law. Significantly, Judge Analisa Torres ruled, preliminarily, that state gambling laws do apply.
Two days earlier, a Michigan state court granted the Michigan Gaming Control Board’s request for a temporary restraining order (“TRO”) against KalshiEX, LLC, with a daily fine of US$120,000 if Kalshi does not immediately cease all sports betting activities in Michigan. Kalshi had previously failed to get a federal court to enjoin the state action. One of the main arguments that seems to have swayed the state judge was Kalshi accepting patrons under 21 years old, the minimum age to place bets with state-licensed bookmakers.
Days before Trump began his war against Iran, one or more insiders who knew his top-secret military plans opened accounts on the other big operator, Polymarket, and placed US$529 million in winning trades, betting on the exact day that air-strikes would begin.
But there is a bigger problem, which so far has gotten little attention: Kalshi has refused to pay US$54 million to traders who won their bets that Iranian leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei would leave office before March 1, 2026. The winners’ class action lawsuit alleges that Kalshi continued to take bets on February 28th, even as reports spread throughout the world of U.S-Israeli air-strikes on the Iranian leaders. Kalshi asserts that it had a rule that “leaving office” does not include the Ayatollah being killed. A bizarre claim to make, given that his being killed was one of the most likely outcomes.
Kalshi has given back the winners’ original bets.
Gamblers will put up with a game if it’s the only game in town, even when they know the game is rigged so that insiders will win. What they won’t put up with is when no one is winning.
So, why is Kalshi risking its reputation? Why won’t Kalshi pay winners?
If you believed the prediction market companies, this problem shouldn’t exist. Kalshi should have no interest in whether any bet is won or lost.
One of the most important arguments that prediction markets make is that they are not at all like bookies. These are contracts only between individuals, they claim, which the markets simply facilitate. They assert that there can only be a bet on a future event occurring if there is somebody on the other side who is putting up money that the event will not occur.
This is not true.
The people who won the US$529 million bet on when the war would begin sometimes put up as little as ten cents to win a dollar. Were there really people willing to bet as much as 90 cents, to win only a dollar, that Trump would not start a war with Iran? Does anyone believe that gamblers put up more than US$400 million, on 1 to 9 odds, no less, that Donald Trump would not bomb Iran?
So, who would lose if Kalshi must pay winners? In a Massachusetts case, the judge found that “Kalshi had an affiliated entity that places buy and sell orders, ensuring that both yes and no contracts can be purchased for any given event at all times.”
So Kalshi would have to pay winners out of its own pockets, just like a bookie. Kalshi probably uses an affiliated entity to make its wagers for itself, so that when those bets lose big time, as now, the affiliate alone can declare bankruptcy.
The online commodities industry likes to say it is merely providing a platform for individuals to bet against each other. It may be a platform, but it is also a market, with market makers. Kalshi’s affiliate does exactly what a market maker is supposed to do: put up the money when there is nobody to take the other side of a trade. Of course, market makers are required to pay winners.
Futures prediction markets assert they are commodities markets, no different than other futures markets, such as those on the future price of corn or oil. Kalshi and Polymarket make contracts on other future events, including elections, sports and wars. States, especially those with state-licensed gambling like Nevada, say that betting on who will win a football game makes them no different than sports books.
First, it is important to clear up one general misconception. Whether Kalshi, Polymarket and their smaller competitors are gambling has almost nothing to do with whether they are legal. Traders in all commodities markets put up money on future uncertain events in the hope of making a profit: consideration, chance and prize are the dictionary definition of gambling. But many forms of gambling are legal, including state lotteries, licensed bookies and commodities markets.
Conclusion
The current confusion over futures prediction markets on sports, elections and wars, starts with society’s historic antipathy toward gambling. State legislatures have outlawed most forms of gambling from the beginning. This included activities that looked like gambling, including insurance, auctions and securities and commodities markets.
Because prediction markets are not gambling these gaming devices could be placed in bars, gas stations, convenience stores, and coffee shops. And amusement arcades. Even zoning laws might not apply; Nevada places limits on convenience gambling, what they call restricted licenses, including location and limiting true slot machines to 15. Because restricted licenses are part of Nevada’s Gaming Statutes, they cannot be used to restrict commodities trading authorized by federal law.
The federal Wire Act prevents cross-border sports betting. If prediction markets succeed in being ruled to be merely commodities, they can take bets from everywhere. And there is nothing to stop them from offering games that play exactly like slot machines based on real-world events on everyone’s home computers and cell phones.
So, in five or ten years these futures prediction markets will either be outlawed, or the country will be awash in unlicensed and unregulated “commodities” trading.
Full article content: https://www.gamblingandthelaw.com/why-congress-and-the-courts-should-but-wont-outlaw-futures-prediction-markets/
* Prepared for the National Council of Legislators from Gaming States, Summer 2026 Conference, San Diego, California
© Copyright July 20, 2026, all rights reserved worldwide. Gambling and the Law® is a registered trademark of Professor I. Nelson Rose, www.GamblingAndTheLaw.com.













